Contact information

MidTide Media 123 Pleasant St Suite 300. Marblehead, MA 01945.

Do democracies die without external enemies?

The United States has come a long way from its “consensus” period in the cold war. Many people worry that the Republic is falling apart. There are indeed similarities between the United States and the late Roman Republic, and even the late Athenian Democracy, which tore themselves apart internally. There is a growing sense that democracy, even in Europe, is starting to go off the rails. 

The United States is a very old democracy, historically. It is the oldest living democracy. Our peer in liberty, France, is working on its fifth Republic. Three of its four failures were internal collapses of the democratic institutions or civil society. 

In Wedgedwe put forth the theory that structural changes drove a breakdown in political dialogue and a suppression of the middle ground. This led to increased polarization, which threatens the nation. We note that growing polarization began in the early to mid 1990s.

However this period also coincides with the end of the Cold War and the beginning of a true Pax Americana. That is, the United States had (and still has) no credible serious threats to its security. 

An alternative explanation to America’s growing polarization is that, lacking an external enemy, its tribal identities are changing and factionalism is rising within. Below we’ll discuss such a theory and then walk through a bit of American history to see how it applies to the republic. 

(Note we have omitted for now an exploration of other democracies because this post got long!)

Fated to Tribalism?

In-group / out-group theory claims that humans tend to psychologically join and identify within groups (let’s call them “tribes”), which always requires psychologically defining those outside that group. 

This tendency is so universal and arbitrary that when Jane Elliot split her class into students of brown eyes and blue eyes, they began acting as if they were generations-long enemies. They even fabricated reasons why one eye color made you a better person.

Such a theory suggests that tribalism is inevitable. Whether it’s racial, ethnic, national, religious, cultural, classist, or ideological (or based on your Pokemon GO team), we’ll find a tribe to join and another to hate.

Let’s say a nation or a group of nation faces an existential threat from another nation or group of nations. These two groups, to form alliances or national unity, have already successfully created a tribal identity. In this case, the existential threat is so pressing that other tribal identities are subordinated to the national or alliance identity. As long as the military threat remains, the identity is strong. Consider:

  • Greek vs. Barbarian, or Roman vs. Barbarian (in antiquity)
  • Chinese vs. Barbarian (China until the 20th century, on and off, depending on threat level)
  • Islam vs. Christendom (in the Umayyad advance and Crusade counter-attacks)
  • Protestants vs. Catholics (30 years war and other wars of reformation)
  • Allies vs. Fascists (WWII)
  • Free World vs. Communist World (Cold War)

You get the idea.

In a democracy, these conditions create a unified tribal identity. 

When you’re talking with people in your tribe, you treat them like humans. 

What happens when there is no external threat? Citizens form new in groups and new out groups. Perhaps they are racial, ethnic, political, religious, classist. Sometimes it’s sports teams–from soccer hooliganism to the Nika Riots, people find stupid reasons to identify as a tribe and then fight. 

If humans will inevitably form tribes, then in peacetime, these tribes are internal. Instead of devising an external tribe and threat, humans devise internal tribes and threats. 

And if that is true, then democracies are always in peril when there is no outside threat. Factions will emerge and will risk tearing apart the democracy itself.

Internal and External Threats in the History of the United States

A very sloppy look at the United States’ history suggests this may be true, at least for America. Just after independence, the United States was highly united under Washington. The fledgling republic was fragile.

Parties immediately sprung into the system at Washington’s departure. They were not accounted for in the building of the Constitution and immediately perverted the system from how it was meant to work.

Besides these parties, the north/south, industrial/rural, free/slave split in the United States was a very natural line along which to define tribes. But through the early 1800s, the United States fought a war with Britain, one with Mexico, and many with Native American tribes as it expanded to conquer as much of the continent as it could. With external enemies, the US held together with compromise after compromise.

When it had won the Continent, it tore itself apart in the Civil War. The republic was, in a sense, saved, but only by the complete military subjugation of the south by the north. 

The US then fought Spain and the Philippines as it pushed its sphere beyond its borders in the later 1800s. Pushing Europe out of the eastern Pacific and the Caribbean continued until World War 1. 

We can perhaps count the Great Depression as an external threat. World War 2 followed. The Cold War followed. Then the 1990s came along and the US really wasn’t under any territorial or existential threat (forced or chosen) anymore–perhaps for the first time since just before the Civil War. This period was called the American Consensus period

Consider that during this period, large swaths of the American population were oppressed or marginalized. Women had to fight for the right to vote, as well as fight an ongoing societal struggle in the feminist movements. Black Americans had to fight for civil rights and an end of active, deliberate, legal and sanctioned oppression. Japanese-Americans were interred in concentration camps. The 1950s included a Communist scare and the McCarthy era. The 1960s saw massive social upheaval and rioting. The 1970s saw Vietnam.

And yet there is evidence that Republicans and Democrats worked together in Congress and talked together at home, despite massive differences. It seems amazing now: the issues that we fight over so bitterly, that seem to threaten to tear us asunder, were much greater in magnitude than they are today. 

And it was the 1990s, as we point out in Wedged, where partisanship and polarization began to grow. Interestingly, it was a time of comparative national naivete to the social issues in the country (racial biases, gender and LGBT biases, economic inequality, and other issues that we discuss with great heat today). 

Is this polarization growing simply because we are looking for an enemy, and have found that enemy in ourselves? This is an open question and we want your input.

Related Posts

42 Comments

  • alex, October 25, 2017 @ 2:13 pm Reply

    I wonder if this relates to the ‘higher authority’ in negotiating. The advice I have read in the ‘secrets of power negotiating’ is to always leave yourself a ‘higher authority’ to defer to if you can. Like wise to make sure that you are speaking to the final decision maker on the other side if you can.

    So for instance; I got a quote from a scaffolder the other day. I told him that I’d speak to my wife and get back to him. My wife being the ‘higher authority’. If you are selling into a company the the question is ‘do you have the budget for this. If they say no, its Jane’s budget, then you want to say: ‘Shall I come in when Jane has some time’ you do this to remove their ability to defer to a higher authority.

    While there is an external enemy, they are like the higher authority. A leader can say: I’d be able to make you voters all super wealthy and happy if it weren’t for that pesky soviet block’.

    As soon as there is no plausible external downward pressure on living standards, all the leader is left with is, we will make ‘efficiency’ savings. It a bit like say newtonian physics is the source of our problems, or sometimes life just sucks. Its not very utopian.

    So it Leaves the field open for someone to say, that you the leader are the problem.

    I notice that Trump, the negotiator and chief has created lots of external enemies: North Korea, China etc.

    • Erik Fogg, October 26, 2017 @ 6:34 pm Reply

      That is a very cool model I had not considered at all. It’s making me think of World War Two: "yes you’re all working harder than ever and you literally have to still grow your own food on top of it and pay 93% marginal taxes because Nazis" and everyone goes "yeah okay that’s actually quite reasonable" and knuckles down. (Additionally I have a burgeoning theory that "wartime economics" defies most of what we think of as basic economics because everyone temporarily stops being a rational/selfish actor in any recognizable way.)

      And yes agreed that Trump is definitely pulling the external threat card. The only important question: how many people buy it?

  • Joe, October 26, 2017 @ 8:25 am Reply

    Yep I think this is happening

    • Erik Fogg, October 26, 2017 @ 6:27 pm Reply

      Joe, you know I have always loved and appreciated your directness.

  • jo, February 13, 2018 @ 1:26 am Reply

    define state?

    • Erik Fogg, February 13, 2018 @ 2:38 am Reply

      Probably the post-Waterloo western nation-state, specifically.

  • Candor tree service company, March 13, 2021 @ 2:07 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Info to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • sex workers for hire, March 31, 2021 @ 8:20 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Info on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • Jake Medwell, April 8, 2021 @ 8:54 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Information here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • 5d diamond painting instruction, May 8, 2021 @ 12:23 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Information here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • W88 casino, May 21, 2021 @ 2:22 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Info here to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • http://familysaversonline.com/, May 31, 2021 @ 9:29 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Information here to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • san jose del cabo real estate, June 2, 2021 @ 5:44 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Info to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • gửi hàng đi mỹ, June 14, 2021 @ 7:03 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • microsoft exchange hosting fiyat, June 26, 2021 @ 11:31 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • it danışmanlığı, June 28, 2021 @ 4:06 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • Supercritical CO2 Extraction Machine, July 15, 2021 @ 9:22 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Info here to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • espiar whatsapp, July 24, 2021 @ 5:58 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • Buy FN Rifles Online, October 6, 2021 @ 10:52 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • cavapoo puppy, November 17, 2021 @ 11:34 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • สล็อตเว็บตรง, December 7, 2021 @ 11:40 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • บาคาร่า1688, January 8, 2022 @ 12:48 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Information on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • remington guns, February 12, 2022 @ 6:38 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Info here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • Esport, February 15, 2022 @ 5:57 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • sbo, March 3, 2022 @ 12:24 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Information here to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • สโบเบ็ต, March 3, 2022 @ 1:20 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Information on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • ถาดกระดาษ, May 30, 2022 @ 4:36 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • สล็อตวอเลท ไม่มีขั้นต่ำ, July 21, 2022 @ 12:02 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] There you can find 67600 more Info to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • pour plus d'informations, January 10, 2023 @ 11:44 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • Explorer, January 12, 2023 @ 3:07 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Info here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • Investment opportunities, January 30, 2023 @ 8:52 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • magic boom bars dc, February 9, 2023 @ 3:54 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Information here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • cannabis delivery, February 18, 2023 @ 9:38 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • best dumps site, February 19, 2023 @ 5:45 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Information here on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • แจกเครดิตฟรี, February 25, 2023 @ 3:25 am Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • download instagram video iphone, March 2, 2023 @ 2:07 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More here to that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • rich89bet, March 4, 2023 @ 11:23 pm Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] There you will find 44760 more Information on that Topic: reconsidermedia.com/do-democracies-die-without-external-enemies/ […]

  • warm jazz instrumental music, October 10, 2023 @ 9:19 pm Reply

    warm jazz instrumental music

  • healing music, November 6, 2023 @ 7:29 pm Reply

    healing music

  • jazz cafe, November 16, 2023 @ 2:42 pm Reply

    jazz cafe

  • jazz for relaxation, November 20, 2023 @ 7:02 am Reply

    jazz for relaxation

  • relax everyday, November 22, 2023 @ 9:14 am Reply

    relax everyday

Leave a Reply